Podcast: Play in new window | Download
One of those episodes where the host shoots off a quick review (of Hulk Team-Up Featuring Hulk and Uncanny X-Men) and Pat gives us the new releases, Steve entertains us, and a couple voicemails pop up.
Discuss this episode on the forum.
The Quahaugs, Weeds Amongst Flowers (http://www.thequahaugs.com/)
Voicemail: (206) 312-5239
Email: marvelnoise@comicbooknoise.com
FriendFeed: http://friendfeed.com/davidaprice
Facebook Marvel Noise Group: http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=12732697211
Facebook Comic Book Noise Extended Family Group: http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=5309074819
Podcast Alley: http://www.podcastalley.com/podcast_details.php?pod_id=51305
ComicSpace: http://www.comicspace.com/marvelnoise/
Digg: http://digg.com/podcasts/Marvel_Noise
League of Comic Book Podcasts: http://leagueofcomicbookpodcasts.blogspot.com/
Comics Podcasts Network: http://www.comicspodcasts.com/
Shipping October 28, 2009:
Amazing Spider-Man Presents Anti-Venom New Ways To Live #2 $3.99
Anita Blake Vampire Hunter Laughing Corpse Book 3 Executioner #1 $3.99
Avengers The Initiative #29 Incentive Super Hero Squad Variant Cover – [PI]
Avengers The Initiative #29 Regular Matteo De Longis Cover $2.99
Dark Avengers Ares #1 $3.99
Dark Reign The List Part 2 Daredevil 2nd Ptg Variant Cover $3.99
Dark Reign The List Part 6 Punisher Incentive Frank Cho Hero Variant Cover – [PI]
Dark Reign The List Part 6 Punisher Regular John Romita Jr Cover $3.99
Dark Reign The List Part 7 Wolverine Incentive Frank Cho Hero Variant Cover – [PI]
Dark Reign The List Part 7 Wolverine Regular Esad Ribic Cover $3.99
Dark Reign Young Avengers #5 $3.99
Enders Shadow Command School #2 $3.99
Fantastic Four Visionaries John Byrne Vol 1 TP New Printing $24.99
Fantastic Four Vol 3 #572 Incentive Dale Eaglesham Human Torch Variant Cover – [PI]
Fantastic Four Vol 3 #572 Incentive Super Hero Squad Variant Cover – [PI]
Fantastic Four Vol 3 #572 Regular Alan Davis Cover $2.99
Guardians Of The Galaxy Vol 2 #19 $2.99
Halo Helljumper #4 $3.99
Hulk Vol 2 #16 Incentive Ed McGuiness Deadpool Variant Cover – [PI]
Hulk Vol 2 #16 Incentive Ed McGuinness Variant Cover – [PI]
Hulk Vol 2 #16 Regular Ian Churchill Cover $3.99
Hulk Vol 3 Hulk No More HC $19.99
Incredible Hercules #137 $2.99
Invincible Iron Man Vol 2 Worlds Most Wanted Book 1 TP $14.99
Kabuki Vol 7 The Alchemy TP $24.99
Laurell K Hamiltons Anita Blake Vampire Hunter Laughing Corpse Vol 1 Animator TP $16.99
Marvel Adventures Spider-Man #56 $2.99
Marvel Divas #4 $3.99
Marvel Holiday Spectacular 2009 Regular Ed McGuinness Cover $9.99
Marvel Holiday Spectacular 2009 Variant Spider-Man Balloon Cover $9.99
Marvel Masterworks Amazing Spider-Man Vol 3 TP Book Market Edition $24.99
Marvel Masterworks Amazing Spider-Man Vol 3 TP Direct Market Edition $24.99
Marvel Masterworks Atlas Era Menace Vol 1 HC Regular Dust Jacket $59.99
Marvel Masterworks Atlas Era Menace Vol 1 HC Variant Dust Jacket $59.99
Models Inc #3 Regular Scott Clark Cover $3.99
Models Inc #3 Variant Greg Land Zombie Cover $3.99
Ms Marvel Vol 2 #46 Incentive Sana Takeda Zombie Variant Cover – [PI]
Ms Marvel Vol 2 #46 Regular Sana Takeda Cover $2.99
New Avengers #58 $3.99
New Avengers Vol 10 Power TP $15.99
New Mutants Vol 3 #6 Incentive Zombie Variant Cover (Necrosha Part 2) – [PI]
New Mutants Vol 3 #6 Regular Adam Kubert Cover (Necrosha Part 2) $2.99
Nova Vol 4 #30 $2.99
Punisher Vol 7 #10 Incentive Rest In Pieces Variant Cover – [PI]
Punisher Vol 7 #10 Regular Mike McKone Cover $2.99
Riftwar #5 $3.99
Secret Warriors #9 Incentive Gerald Parel Zombie Variant Cover – [PI]
Secret Warriors #9 Incentive Super Hero Squad Variant Cover – [PI]
Secret Warriors #9 Regular Jim Cheung Cover $2.99
Skaar Son Of Hulk #16 $2.99
Spider-Man American Son HC $19.99
Spider-Man Clone Saga #2 $3.99
Spider-Man Newspaper Strips HC $39.99
Spin Angels #3 $5.99
Ultimate Comics Armor Wars #1 Incentive Retailer Summit Steve Kurth Villain Sketch Cover – [PI]
Ultimate Comics Armor Wars #2 $3.99
Ultimate Comics Avengers #3 $3.99
Vengeance Of The Moon Knight #1 2nd Ptg David Finch Sketch Variant Cover $3.99
War Machine Vol 2 #10 (Dark Reign Tie-In) $2.99
Wolverine Art Appreciation One Shot $3.99
Wolverine First Class #20 $2.99
Wolverine Old Man Logan HC Regular Steve McNiven Cover $34.99
Wolverine Old Man Logan HC Variant Michael Turner Cover $34.99
Wolverine Weapon X #6 Adam Kubert Cover $3.99
Wolverine Weapon X #6 Joe Kubert Cover $3.99
X Necrosha One Shot Incentive Clayton Crain Variant Cover (Necrosha Part 1) – [PI]
X Necrosha One Shot Regular Clayton Crain Cover (Necrosha Part 1) $3.99
X-Factor Vol 3 #50 $3.99
X-Force Vol 3 #20 (Necrosha Tie-In) $2.99
X-Men Forever Vol 2 #10 Incentive Zombie Variant Cover – [PI]
X-Men Forever Vol 2 #10 Regular Tom Grummett Cover $3.99
Product Updates:
- Avengers: Initiative #29 (AUG090457D, $2.99; FOC 10/08/09) will have art by Jorge Molina, not Rafa Sandoval.
- Dark Avengers: Ares #1 (AUG090465D, $3.99; FOC 10/01/09) will have pencils by Manuel Garcia, not Cary Nord.
- Models Inc. #3 (Regular/Zombie Variant: AUG090491-2D, $3.99; FOC 10/08/09) will now have a six-page Zombie Model back-up story by Paul Tobin and Colleen Coover along with the solicited 22-page main story. The book’s total page count (32) and $3.99 price are unchanged. Additionally, the Zombie Variant – featuring a cover by Greg Land — may be ordered in any quantity without restrictions, rather than as a 1:10 variant, as solicited.
- Models Inc. #3 (Reg./Var.: AUG090491-2D, $3.99) will be 40 pages, not 32 pages, to accommodate the main story and a zombie back-up story.
- Ms. Marvel #46 Zombie Variant (AUG090494D, $2.99; FOC 10/08/09) will have cover art by Sana Takeda.
- Secret Warriors #9 Zombie Variant (AUG090502D, $2.99; FOC 10/08/09) will have cover art by Gerald Parel.
- Spin Angels (#3: AUG090438D, FOC 10/08/09; #4: OCT090481D, FOC 11/12/09; $5.99 ea.) will expand from a three-part limited series to four parts.
- X-Force/New Mutants: Necrosha (AUG090522D, $3.99; FOC 10/01/09) has been retitled X Necrosha One-Shot.
- X-Force/New Mutants: Necrosha Crain Variant (AUG09-0523D, $3.99; FOC 10/01/09) has been retitled X-Necrosha One-shot Crain Variant.
- In addition to Clayton Crain, X-Necrosha One-shot (AUG090522D, $3.99; FOC 10/01/09) will also have pencils by Ibraim Roberson.
- Wolverine HC: Old Man Logan & Variant (AUG090551-2D, $34.99) will have 224 pages, not 208 pages.
- Wolverine HC: Old Man Logan (Reg./DM: AUG090551-2D, $34.99; FOC 09/10/09) was correctly listed on page 88 of the August Marvel Previews as a Regular HC. However, it was incorrectly listed on the Diamond order form as a Premiere HC. Please be aware of this when ordering.
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
Pat! Steve! A voicemail!! And our host rambles on a bit about Essential Punisher Vol. 3.
Discuss this episode on the forum.
4Tex, Wonderful Thing (http://www.4tex-online.de/)
Voicemail: (206) 312-5239
Email: marvelnoise@comicbooknoise.com
FriendFeed: http://friendfeed.com/davidaprice
Facebook Marvel Noise Group: http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=12732697211
Facebook Comic Book Noise Extended Family Group: http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=5309074819
Podcast Alley: http://www.podcastalley.com/podcast_details.php?pod_id=51305
ComicSpace: http://www.comicspace.com/marvelnoise/
Digg: http://digg.com/podcasts/Marvel_Noise
League of Comic Book Podcasts: http://leagueofcomicbookpodcasts.blogspot.com/
Comics Podcasts Network: http://www.comicspodcasts.com/
Items Shipping October 21, 2009:
Amazing Spider-Man Vol 2 #609 $2.99
Captain America Road To Reborn HC $24.99
Dark Avengers #10 $3.99
Dark Reign The List Part 1 Avengers 2nd Ptg Variant Cover $3.99
Dark Reign The List Part 5 Hulk Incentive Frank Cho Hero Variant Cover – [PI]
Dark Reign The List Part 5 Hulk Regular Ben Oliver Cover $3.99
Dark Wolverine #79 Incentive Daniel Acuna Young Guns Variant Cover – [PI]
Dark Wolverine #79 Incentive Francesco Mattina Zombie Variant Cover – [PI]
Dark Wolverine #79 Regular Greg Land Cover $2.99
Deadpool Merc With A Mouth #4 $2.99
Deadpool Poster Book $5.99
Dominic Fortune #3 $3.99
Incredible Hulk Vol 3 #603 Incentive Salvador Espin Zombie Variant Cover – [PI]
Incredible Hulk Vol 3 #603 Incentive Super Hero Squad Variant Cover – [PI]
Incredible Hulk Vol 3 #603 Regular Salvador Espin Cover $3.99
Invincible Iron Man #19 Incentive Super Hero Squad Variant Cover – [PI]
Invincible Iron Man #19 Regular Salvador Larroca Cover $3.99
Lockjaw And The Pet Avengers HC $24.99
Marvel Adventures Avengers Vol 10 Invasion TP Digest $9.99
Marvel Masterworks Inhumans Vol 1 HC Regular Dust Jacket $54.99
Marvel Masterworks Inhumans Vol 1 HC Variant Dust Jacket $54.99
Mighty Avengers #30 Incentive Super Hero Squad Variant Cover -[PI]
Mighty Avengers #30 Regular Marko Djurdjevic Cover $2.99
Punisher Noir #3 Regular Tim Bradstreet Cover $3.99
Punisher Noir #3 Variant Dennis Calero Cover $3.99
Runaways Rock Zombies TP $14.99
Runaways Vol 9 Dead Wrong TP Digest $9.99
Skrull Kill Krew Vol 2 #5 Incentive Top Cow Variant Cover (Dark Reign Tie-In) – [PI]
Skrull Kill Krew Vol 2 #5 Regular Mario Alberti Cover (Dark Reign Tie-In) $3.99
Spider-Man Death And Dating TP $19.99
Spider-Woman Vol 4 #2 $2.99
Stand Soul Survivors #1 Incentive Mike Perkins Variant Cover – [PI]
Stand Soul Survivors #1 Regular Lee Bermejo Cover $3.99
Thor Tales Of Asgard By Stan Lee & Jack Kirby #6 $3.99
Thunderbolts #137 $3.99
Thunderbolts Burning Down The House TP $14.99
War Machine Vol 1 Iron Heart TP $15.99
Wolverine Dark Wolverine Vol 1 The Prince HC $24.99
Wolverine Noir HC $19.99
Wolverine Origins #41 $2.99
X-Men Legacy #228 $2.99
Product Updates:
- Dark Wolverine #79 Zombie Variant (AUG090517D, $2.99; FOC 10/01/09) will have cover art by Francesco Mattina.
- Dark Wolverine Premiere HC Vol. 1: Prince (AUG090562D, $24.99; FOC 09/10/09) will be 112 pages, not 120 pages.
- Dark Wolverine Premiere HC Vol. 1: Prince (AUG090562D, $24.99) will now be titled Wolverine: Dark Wolverine Premiere HC Vol. 1 – Prince.
- Incredible Hulk #603 (Reg./Var.:AUG090477-8D, $3.99; FOC 10/01/09) will have cover art by Salvador Espin.
- Incredible Hulk #603 (AUG090477D, $3.99) and #604 (SEP090430D, $3.99; FOC 10/29/09) will have art by Ariel Olivetti and Giuseppe Camuncoli, not Olivetti and Michael Ryan.
- The Olivier Coipel cover shown in the August Marvel Previews for Thor: Tales of Asgard by Lee & Kirby #6 (AUG090503D, $3.99; FOC 09/24/09) is actually the Coipel cover for Thor: Tales of Asgard #4.
- Thunderbolts #137 (AUG090507D FOC 10/01/09) will be: $3.99 and 48 pages, not $2.99 and 32 pages; written by Rick Remender and illustrated by Mahmud Asrar; and feature a cover by Francesco Mattina that was originally scheduled for Thunderbolts #136. The original cover to Thunderbolts #137 will now be the cover to Thunderbolts #136.
- Wolverine Noir Premiere HC (AUG090561D, $19.99; FOC 09/10/09) will be 112 pages, not 120 pages.
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
Don’t let your ears pop or you’ll miss it! Pat’s here with the new releases and the host says very few words, some of them on the Mighty Avengers.
Discuss this episode on the forum.
Loikamania (http://loikamania.blogspot.com)
Velvet Velvet Velvet, Blink (http://www.musicalley.com/music/producers/producerLibrary/www.myspace.com/velvetcubed)
Voicemail: (206) 312-5239
Email: marvelnoise@comicbooknoise.com
FriendFeed: http://friendfeed.com/davidaprice
Facebook Marvel Noise Group: http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=12732697211
Facebook Comic Book Noise Extended Family Group: http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=5309074819
Podcast Alley: http://www.podcastalley.com/podcast_details.php?pod_id=51305
ComicSpace: http://www.comicspace.com/marvelnoise/
Digg: http://digg.com/podcasts/Marvel_Noise
League of Comic Book Podcasts: http://leagueofcomicbookpodcasts.blogspot.com/
Comics Podcasts Network: http://www.comicspodcasts.com/
Items shipping October 14, 2009:
Anita Blake Vampire Hunter Guilty Pleasures Complete Edition HC $34.99
Daredevil Return Of King TP $17.99
Deadpool Vol 3 #15 2nd Ptg Paco Medina Variant Cover $2.99
Deadpool Vol 3 #900 Incentive Dave Johnson Variant Cover – [PI]
Deadpool Vol 3 #900 Regular Dave Johnson Cover $4.99
Enders Game Command School #2 $3.99
GeNext United #5 $3.99
Incredible Hercules #136 Incentive Salvador Espin Zombie Variant Cover – [PI]
Incredible Hercules #136 Regular Rafael Alberquerque Cover $2.99
Invincible Iron Man #17 2nd Ptg Salvador Larroca Variant Cover (Dark Reign Tie-In) $2.99
Iron Man Iron Protocols One Shot $3.99
Kabuki Reflections #15 $5.99
Marvel 1602 New World Fantastick Four HC $24.99
Marvel Adventures Super Heroes #16 $2.99
Marvel Super Hero Squad #2 $2.99
Marvel Zombies 4 HC $19.99
Marvel Zombies Return #2 2nd Ptg Arthur Suydam Variant Cover $3.99
Marvels Project #3 Incentive Gerald Parel Variant Cover – [PI]
Marvels Project #3 Regular Steve McNiven Cover $3.99
Marvels Project #3 Variant Steve Epting Cover $3.99
Mephisto vs HC Premiere Edition Book Market Cover $19.99
Mephisto vs HC Premiere Edition Direct Market Cover $19.99
Moon Knight Vol 5 Down South TP $15.99
Nomad Girl Without A World #2 $3.99
Pride & Prejudice HC $19.99
Punisher Frank Castle #75 Incentive Steve Dillon Variant Cover – [PI]
Punisher Frank Castle #75 Regular Dave Johnson Cover $4.99
Runaways Teenage Wasteland TP $14.99
Torch #1 2nd Ptg Patrick Berkenkotter Variant Cover $3.99
Ultimate Comics Spider-Man #2 2nd Ptg David Lafuente Variant Cover $3.99
Ultimate Wolverine vs Hulk HC $24.99
Uncanny X-Men #516 $2.99
Uncanny X-Men First Class #4 $2.99
Uncanny X-Men Manifest Destiny TP $24.99
Web Of Spider-Man Vol 2 #1 Incentive Mirco Pierfederici Zombie Variant Cover – [PI]
Web Of Spider-Man Vol 2 #1 Regular Pasqual Ferry Cover $3.99
X-Men Forever Vol 2 #9 $3.99
Product Updates:
- Anita Blake, Vampire Hunter: Guilty Pleasures HC (AUG090556D, $34.99) has been retitled Anita Blake, Vampire Hunter: Guilty Pleasures Complete Edition HC.
- Iron Man: Iron Protocols One-shot (AUG090480D, $3.99; FOC 09/24/09) will contain an additional story by Rick Spears & Iban Coello, with no change in the book’s page count or price.
- Incredible Hercules #136 Zombie Variant (AUG090474D, $2.99; FOC 09/24/09) will have cover art by Salvador Espin.
- Marvel Super Hero Squad #2 (AUG090484D, $3.99; FOC 09/24/09) will be written by Mark Hoffmeier, not Paul Tobin.
- Marvel Zombies 4 HC (AUG090554D, $19.99; FOC 09/10/09) will have 128 pages, not 112 pages.
- Web of Spider-Man #1 (AUG090447D, $3.99; FOC 09/24/09) will have a story by Sean McKeever and Stephanie Buscema along with the originally solicited creators. Additionally, the cover to its Zombie Variant (AUG090448D, $3.99; FOC 09/24/09) will be by Mirco Pierfederici.
- X-Men Forever #9 Zombie Variant (AUG090537D, $3.99; FOC 09/24/09) has been cancelled. Issue #10 (AUG090538D, $3.99; FOC 10/08/09) of the series will now have a Zombie Variant Cover.
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
We’re back with the new releases from Pat, the second part of Marvel: The End from Steve, and two calls from Carlos! And the show ends with some comments on Agents of Atlas, Fantastic Four, Punisher, and Uncanny X-Men First Class.
Discuss this episode on the forum.
The Minor Leagues, Good Boys (http://www.minorleaguesmusic.com/)
Voicemail: (206) 312-5239
Email: marvelnoise@comicbooknoise.com
FriendFeed: http://friendfeed.com/davidaprice
Facebook Marvel Noise Group: http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=12732697211
Facebook Comic Book Noise Extended Family Group: http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=5309074819
Podcast Alley: http://www.podcastalley.com/podcast_details.php?pod_id=51305
ComicSpace: http://www.comicspace.com/marvelnoise/
Digg: http://digg.com/podcasts/Marvel_Noise
League of Comic Book Podcasts: http://leagueofcomicbookpodcasts.blogspot.com/
Comics Podcasts Network: http://www.comicspodcasts.com/
Items shipping October 7, 2009:
Amazing Spider-Man Vol 2 #608 70th Anniversary Djurdjevic Variant Cover $2.99
Amazing Spider-Man Vol 2 #608 Regular Adi Granov Cover $2.99
Astonishing X-Men Vol 3 #31 Incentive Phil Jimenez Sketch Cover – [PI]
Astonishing X-Men Vol 3 #31 Incentive Travis Charest Variant Cover – [PI]
Astonishing X-Men Vol 3 #31 Regular Phil Jimenez Cover $2.99
Black Panther Vol 5 #9 $2.99
Cable Vol 2 #19 $2.99
Captain America Theater War Ghosts Of My Country $3.99
Criminal The Sinners #1 $3.50
Daredevil Vol 2 #500 2nd Ptg Patrick Zircher Variant Cover $4.99
Daredevil Vol 2 #501 Incentive Tim Sale Variant Cover – [PI]
Daredevil Vol 2 #501 Regular Esad Ribic Cover $2.99
Dark Reign The List Part 4 Secret Warriors Incentive Frank Cho Hero Variant Cover -[PI]
Dark Reign The List Part 4 Secret Warriors Regular Ed McGuinness Cover $3.99
Dark Reign Zodiac #3 $3.99
Deadpool Vol 3 #14 2nd Ptg Shawn Crystal Variant Cover $2.99
Deadpool Vol 3 #16 $2.99
Doctor Voodoo Avenger Of The Supernatural #1 Incentive Billy Tan Variant Cover – [PI]
Doctor Voodoo Avenger Of The Supernatural #1 Regular Marko Djurdjevic Cover $3.99
Ghost Riders Heavens On Fire #3 $3.99
House Of M Masters Of Evil #3 $3.99
Hulk Vol 2 #14 2nd Ptg Ian Churchill Variant Cover $3.99
Iron Man & The Armor Wars #3 $2.99
Luke Cage Noir #3 Regular Tim Bradstreet Cover $3.99
Luke Cage Noir #3 Variant Dennis Calero Cover $3.99
Marvel Spotlight Deadpool $2.99
Marvel Zombies Return #1 2nd Ptg Arthur Suydam Variant Cover $3.99
Models Inc #2 Regular Scott Clark Cover $3.99
Models Inc #2 Variant Steve Kurth Tabloid Cover $3.99
Official Index To The Marvel Universe #10 $3.99
Spider-Man 1602 #1 $3.99
Starr The Slayer #2 $3.99
Strange Tales Vol 5 #1 2nd Ptg Paul Pope Variant Cover $4.99
Strange Tales Vol 5 #2 Regular Peter Bagge Green Hulk Cover $4.99
Strange Tales Vol 5 #2 Variant Peter Bagge Red Hulk Cover $4.99
Torch #2 $3.99
Ultimate Comics Spider-Man #3 $3.99
Vengeance Of The Moon Knight #2 Incentive Francesco Mattina Zombie Variant Cover – [PI]
Vengeance Of The Moon Knight #2 Regular Leinil Francis Yu Cover $2.99
X-Babies #1 Incentive Humberto Ramos Zombie Variant Cover -[PI]
X-Babies #1 Regular Skottie Young Cover $3.99
X-Babies #1 Variant Jacob Chabot Star Comic Cover $3.99
X-Men vs Agents Of Atlas #1 Incentive Gerald Parel Zombie Variant Cover – [PI]
X-Men vs Agents Of Atlas #1 Incentive Humberto Ramos Variant Cover – [PI]
X-Men vs Agents Of Atlas #1 Regular Ed McGuinness Cover $3.99
Product Updates:
- Astonishing X-Men #31 Free Jimenez Sketch 1:100 Variant is now an Inked Jimenez Variant. This item does not have to be ordered and will be based on orders for the regular cover of Astonishing X-Men #31 (AUG090511D, $2.99; FOC 09/17/09).
- Captain America: Theater of War — Ghosts of My Country (AUG090462D, $3.99) will have art by Elia Bonetti.
- Doctor Voodoo, Avenger of the Supernatural #1 (AUG090463D; FOC 09/17/09) will be 40 pages and $3.99, not 32 pages and $2.99.
- Ghost Riders: Heavens on Fire #3 (AUG090466D, $3.99; FOC 09/17/09) will be 40 pages, not 32 pages.
- Vengeance of Moon Knight #2 Zombie Variant (AUG090506D, $2.99) will have a cover by Francesco Mattina.
- X-Babies #1 and Zombie & Star Comic Chabot Variants (AUG090530-1D & JUL098321D, $3.99) will be 40 pages and will include a 17-page reprint of the X-Babies’ first appearance by Art Adams along with the solicited 22-page main story with no change in price. Additionally, the Zombie Variant cover will be by Humberto Ramos.
- X-Men vs. Agents of Atlas #1 Variant (AUG090455D, $3.99) will have cover art by Humberto Ramos.
Recent Comments